Saturday, April 16, 2022

Retro-Iconic Sonic, University Avenue, Oxford, MS

Today's post highlights Lafayette County, MS, retail.

Not only does it feel like it's been forever since I've written a new blog post, it has literally been forever since I've been to Oxford: after graduating last April, I haven't gone back, meaning this month officially marks one year since I've been in town. It's hard to believe it's been that long, so in an effort to get a little bit of Oxford back in my life, I was inspired to make the Oxford Sonic our first subject after the blog's winter hibernation period.


Courtesy Mutual Art

You might be wondering what's so special about the Oxford Sonic. Honestly, to begin with, not a whole lot was special about it. It was built in 1974 and hadn't really had any significant upgrades in the years since then. You can compare the above image from the restaurant's early days to the images below, taken in more recent years. 

Courtesy Hotty Toddy News

Courtesy Google Maps


Courtesy Google Maps

Really the only thing special about it was that, by way of its lack of upgrades, it remained fairly original, up to and including the pole sign with the classic Sonic logo and slogan. But for a restaurant facility, an old, deteriorating property is, of course, less than desirable.

And so, in early 2017, the Oxford Sonic closed for business, citing plumbing issues beneath the concrete slab, and electrical wiring incapable of supporting modern technology. Oxford residents and Ole Miss students weren't deprived of Sonic -- a new, second location had just opened across town on Jackson Avenue, pictured below. But the original location, on University Avenue, was sadly down for the count. 

Until it wasn't.

New Jackson Avenue Sonic, April 2017

--------------------------------------------------

In the summer of 2018, Oxford news outlets began reporting on the status of the University Avenue Sonic, which had been sitting empty and abandoned. As Channing Green of the Oxford Citizen wrote, "When Sonic Drive-In on University Avenue shut down well over a year ago, the lettering on their sign read 'We will be back.' And they were; however, it was several months later and on the opposite side of town. The Sonic on Jackson Avenue opened near the shopping center containing the Chow King Chinese restaurant and Johnson's Furniture.

Courtesy Oxford Citizen

Image source unknown

"On Monday, however, Sonic owner Ronnie Solberg presented plans to the Courthouse Square Historic Preservation Committee. He's getting ready to reopen the University Avenue location."

"There were a lot of rumors, but we always planned to reopen," Solberg is quoted as saying in the Oxford Eagle in July 2018. "The issue is, we've got to do what's right for Oxford, and that's not a cookie cutter. So it's taking some time."

Indeed, the new building would go through a lengthy design process, resulting in several visits before the Planning Commission and the aforementioned Preservation Committee. It is the thought, consideration, and attention to detail that went into these iterative designs that has made the rebuilt, retro-iconic Sonic such a special topic worth covering. We'll explore more of the design inspirations later in this post, but first, it's worth looking at the existing property prior to its demolition.

Courtesy Twitter

Image source unknown

Courtesy Oxford Eagle

Courtesy Oxford Eagle

In February 2017, the Oxford Police Department posted the top image above to their Twitter account, lamenting the closure of the longtime Oxford square icon. As you can see, the property was roped off by caution tape. The accompanying images present more of an overview of the building as a whole, and show that nothing really changed in the months that ensued, besides more and more weeds taking over the once-popular drive-in. 

I drove past the restaurant in October 2017 and took the pictures below. Many of them are repetitive, but I wanted to be sure and get some form of documentation of the classic structure before it would inevitably be demolished. At this point in time, the property's future and whether the restaurant would return was still in question, as the public announcement of the redesign and reconstruction didn't take place until the summer of 2018. 









That vintage Sonic pole sign was something worth capturing -- surely one of very few remaining in service in the late 2010s -- and would eventually serve as a major inspiration in the design of the new facility. Ultimately, the old drive-in was demolished on Wednesday, September 5, 2018, leaving behind only the longstanding pole sign as a beacon of what once was.

Courtesy Hotty Toddy News

--------------------------------------------------

Part of the problem with the existing Sonic property, as may have been obvious from many of the above images, is that it did not have a driveway turnaround at the front of the building, meaning that if one were to drive around the entire parking lot looking for an open stall, s/he would have to exit the property and reenter traffic before being able to circle back around a second time in hopes of better luck. On busy University Avenue near the Oxford square, this was not a very good situation to put potential customers into. The newly-designed rebuild was primarily engineered to resolve this issue, as well as the other structural and electrical issues that needed upgrading simply due to the age of the 1970s-era building. Everything else we'll be seeing is just the cherry on top of the Sonic Blast.

Due to the restaurant's location, not only its new design, but also just the initial request to demolish and rebuild, had to be presented to, and approved by, the Oxford Courthouse Square Historic Preservation Commission. Franchisee Ronnie Solberg's initial application included several images of the existing conditions at the property, many of which allow us to see closer details beyond the roped-off roadside entrance. These images are reprinted below, and show many signs of aging and deterioration along the property.

Screengrabs from Preservation Commission documents all courtesy of City of Oxford website public viewing










Also attached were site plans, which show the reimagining of the layout so as to include the long-overdue driveway turnaround at the front of the property, as discussed above.

Existing aerial view

Existing site plan

New site plan

Overlay of old building on top of new site plan

--------------------------------------------------

Next comes the fun part -- the design proposals. Included were two distinct design possibilities, each presented in color scheme options of just red, or both red and blue. (Please feel free to click on any of the images in this post to enlarge them, so that you can examine them in closer detail.)



"The first design," reads the June 2018 Preservation Commission document, "is a two-tone scheme with charcoal-colored brick massing, canopy awnings, central tower with flat roof cap, halo channel lettering, LED border, and either red or red & blue accenting."



Meanwhile, "the second design is also a two-tone scheme with charcoal-colored brick massing, canopy awnings, LED border, and halo channel lettering, but offers a different treatment of the central tower. The tower in this alternative does not have a flat roof cap but, instead, is adorned with an antenna-like finial. Like the first option, the building may feature either red or red & blue accenting."

Clearly, at this point it should be obvious that Solberg was not proposing to build your average Sonic Drive-In. Rather, this building would be customized, special and unique to Oxford. As the Oxford Citizen explained, major corporate restaurants like Sonic "typically have to have a certain look, follow a specific color pattern, and be designed in a very particular way. There is, however, some flexibility with this particular restaurant. Due to its unique position in terms of city districting and the historic value of the restaurant, the building will be able to break away from typical corporate design and create something wholly new." 

Preservation Commission documents expound on this by noting that Solberg was looking to "build a new restaurant with architecture that emanates a nostalgic feeling." The Commission saw, amongst its responsibilities, a duty to "discuss whether they believe the new structure is convincingly modern in design without mocking the nostalgia the business evokes from Oxford residents."

--------------------------------------------------

In response to the June 2018 application alternatives presented above, Alyssa Schnugg of the Oxford Eagle reported, "Most of the commissioners said they preferred the red-only accents, but were torn when it came to deciding if they liked the tower with or without the antenna." So, in the following month Solberg and his design team returned, this time with significantly more detailed design proposals in order to facilitate the final selection. Two options were presented... the Retro-Iconic, and the Retro-Modern.






As explained in the above screengrabs from the application document, "the first design -- the Retro-Iconic -- is 'rooted in the 1920s Art Deco' style, and includes a central tower with an antenna-like finial that will have 'LED/neon rings and lighted sphere.' The central tower will also have backlit or exposed LED/neon channel lettering that reads SONIC, and brushed aluminum halo/backlit letters reading OXFORD."





Meanwhile, "the second design -- the Retro-Modern -- similarly has a central tower but with 'post-war mid-century modern design' features. The tower would have 'cleaner lines with [a] cantilevered shed roof trimmed in red neon' lighting and white channel letters reading SONIC."

Obviously, these two designs were more or less the same ones as presented at the previous month's meeting, just a little more fleshed out and detailed. Based on the commission's preference for the red-only accents expressed at that prior meeting, it should be noted that the shared common aspects of the two alternatives had already been finalized: "Both designs feature a common central kitchen building clad in charcoal brick wainscoting, medium-gray upper brick, red glazed porcelain tile accents, cantilevered neon-edged parking canopies, and a seating patio screened by brick planters."

--------------------------------------------------

What's really exciting in all of this, to me, is the obvious inspiration these two design alternatives took from Sonic's past. This inspiration is most easily seen in the presence of the old-school, blocky, italicized SONIC lettering, matching the classic pole sign that had been an icon at the Oxford location for years. (Incidentally, similar signage survived at the Olive Branch, MS, Sonic until 2014, some street view images of which are shown below and more documentation of which can be seen in l_dawg2000's album on flickr, at this link). 

Image source unknown

Courtesy Pinterest

Olive Branch, MS, Sonic, 2014 street view. Courtesy Google Maps

Olive Branch, MS, Sonic, 2014 street view. Courtesy Google Maps

Perhaps less obvious, though, is that the Retro-Iconic design in particular goes far beyond just the classic logo. Instead, that design goes all the way back to Sonic's roots, with the antenna finial/spire reaching out of the top of the building recalling the chain's original association with radio signals and "Service with the Speed of Sound." Below is an illustrated reproduction of one of those vintage signs, as well as some actual historic images with that logo.

Courtesy Dribbble

Courtesy Pinterest

Courtesy The Daily Meal

I'm curious to hear which of the two design alternatives you prefer -- let me know in the comments below -- but it probably shouldn't come as a surprise that the Preservation Commission was swayed in much the same way I was by the nod to Sonic's past. "Of the two designs presented, the commission gave its endorsement for an Art-Deco 'Retro-Iconic' design, which will feature a gray and red exterior with a concrete wall fencing in part of the patio. On the inside of the wall will be a bench for diners, with the Sonic logo on the outside and a flower bed surrounding it," wrote the Oxford Citizen.

"A distinguishing feature of the building will be a spire fashioned after Sonic's iconic radio tower antenna logo. Towering above the restaurant's one-story canopy will be a gray brushed aluminum antenna, adorned with the drive-in's signature red LED neon light trim and topped with a red LED neon ball."

You have to imagine that Sonic corporate had some involvement in approving this design also, so it's especially cool to think that higher-ups within the company, too, saw the value in not only allowing the Oxford location to have a custom look, but more specifically to have that look evoke so much nostalgia harkening back to the chain's roots. This was a really special project for sure, and I'm glad it took place when it did, because who knows what would have happened had it occurred after Sonic's recent early 2020 rebrand, which included a new logo, advertising/marketing identity, and redesigned restaurant prototype as shown below.

Courtesy Inspire Brands

--------------------------------------------------

Still of concern after approving the Retro-Iconic design alternative was ironing out the final details and actually crafting the official construction plans, exterior elevations, etc. In its July 2018 response, the Preservation Commission did suggest that the signage elements shown in the renderings presented earlier in this post should be tweaked, as noted in the excerpts below:

By right, businesses in the City are allowed three signs. ... The existing Sonic only has two signage elements -- a pole sign and a wall sign on the portion of the structure facing the street, toward the rear of the building. The applicant is proposing signage on the tower (in what appears to be three locations), on the front "curb wall" (in what appears to be two locations), and to refurbish and relocate the existing SONIC pole sign (which is approximately 22 feet in height). ... Staff believes that the cumulative amount of signage proposed gives a rather cluttered appearance, especially when combined with the multiple ordering board stations signage.

Staff believes that fewer signs are needed (as locating the business will not be difficult) and that if retained, the pole sign should be substantially reduced in height. ... New businesses are permitted only monument or wall signs. Despite the nostalgia factor for Sonic, the existing pole sign is very suburban in height (designed to catch the eye of cars approaching from a distance), and out of place (at that height) in an urbanizing corridor like this corner of University Avenue. Staff recommends that, if retained, the pole sign should be reduced in height to no more than 12 to 15 feet (such as the [nearby] Goodyear or McAlister's signs).


Solberg and the design team working with Sonic Properties adjusted the design proposal in tandem, sadly resulting in the elimination of all of the localized "OXFORD" signs from the structure. Still, though, the retro "SONIC" logos were retained, and in fact wound up with even more prominence given that the logo is what replaced the town name lettering front-and-center on the building, running vertically directly beneath the antenna element. See the adjusted rendering below, followed by exterior construction elevations.








Also spoiled in the above excerpts was the reveal that the restaurant's historic sign would be staying, just refaced and relocated. "The vintage Sonic pole sign will remain, but move from its current location to the southeast corner of the property, and lowered to comply with current city ordinances." The below screengrab shows the new facing of the sign as compared to the original one. While it's sad that the original sign couldn't be cleaned up and saved, I can understand the installation of a new one; and while it's not exact, the design matches pretty dang closely. It's nice to see the amount of effort that was put into that, anyway.




Ignore the giant orb in the sky -- I accidentally had my flash on :P

Courtesy Oxford Eagle

In November 2018, a variance allowing the building to be set back far enough to accommodate the new driveway turnaround between the patio and public sidewalk was approved, and construction commenced. In addition to the above images showing the newly refaced and relocated pole sign as well as the new building in progress, Google Maps also captured the construction in its June 2019 street view, screenshots of which are presented below.

This and the eight below images courtesy Google Maps



Note the new location, as well as the shrunken height, of the pole sign, as well as the driveway turnaround in front of the building.






--------------------------------------------------

Courtesy Twitter

On July 20, 2019, the Twitter account @OleMissSonic was created, sharing the above image with the caption, "We are getting closer!" Then, finally, after more than two and a half years, the Sonic on University Avenue celebrated its grand reopening on Monday, August 5, 2019. I drove by the restaurant a little over a month later, on September 22, 2019, and captured the below images. I was thoroughly impressed with how well the new drive-in turned out, and I hope you will be, as well.

The pole sign is now right next to the entrance to the property.

Note that the little "enter" and "exit" signs not only mimic the classic "SONIC" logo font...

...the arrows themselves, as shown in this rendering, are actually a nod to Sonic's present, as that shape is the same as the background shape in Sonic's then-current logo!

The finial is looking good!

View of some of the drive-in stalls beneath the new canopy

Wide view, including the driveway turnaround

Front view -- notice no signage was placed on the patio wall after all.

The roof above the patio is slightly angled upward.

I think going with the red-only accents was the right choice.

Refaced and relocated pole sign, with Ole Miss pride on the message board and the Oxford water tower in the background!

Close-up of the finished product.

It is my opinion that the rebuilt University Avenue Sonic is something unique and special that Oxford should be proud of. The callbacks to Sonic's past are deep-seated in the design, and lovingly and meticulously articulated in the construction. The new building truly is retro-iconic, and as the image below proves, it looks pretty darn fantastic with all the LED and neon elements lit up at night, too! Hats off to this reimagined version of America's Drive-In.

Courtesy Google Maps

--------------------------------------------------

I hope y'all enjoyed this post, and for those celebrating, have a happy Easter this weekend. I look forward to hopefully getting the blog back into gear over the coming months, so keep an eye out for new posts in the future! Until then and as always, thanks for reading, and have fun exploring the retail world wherever you are :)

Retail Retell

Thursday, March 17, 2022

The Mid-South Retail Blog Walks Into a Bar (of Soap, That Is)

     Through the years, Memphis has given birth to and become home to the headquarters of a number of retailers and other large businesses. Chains that were founded in Memphis, as well as chains currently headquartered in Memphis, include big names like AutoZone, Holiday Inn, and Malco Theaters. In addition to those big names of today, some major players that are no longer with us once called Memphis home too, such as Seessel's and Fred's (both of which have been popular topics on the Mid-South Retail Blog, as you can explore by clicking on those links). The subject of today's MSRB post might not be as large as some of those companies I just named (at least yet), but this rather new retailer with a Memphis connection is growing and expanding into a rather large company with a national presence at the moment. Today's post isn't very long, but it's another way that the retail of the Mid-South has crossed itself with the retail of Florida!

All interior photos are courtesy of reviewers who posted to Google Maps - the exterior photos were all taken by AFB.

     Hello there everyone, it's the Albertsons Florida Blogger writing for you once again on the Mid-South Retail Blog. As you may remember, I wrote a post for the MSRB last March, where we explored a former Fred's store in Titusville, FL that had since become an antique mall. As you may know, our usual MSRB host, Retail Retell, has been a bit busy lately. So while Retail Retell is working on other things, I'm here to fill the void for everyone with this post. My post today will be featuring a retail chain with Memphis roots called Buff City Soap (the company's name a play on Memphis's nickname of "the bluff city"). Buff City Soap is a company that specializes in the sale of homemade and organic soaps, and has been on a bit of a growth spurt lately. I actually had no idea about Buff City Soap until Retail Retell mentioned the company in passing during conversation of ours a while back. One day last fall when I was in Orlando, I had stopped to photograph a new Publix store in a former Lucky's Market building. On my way back to the car, I happened to look over at the little strip mall next door to the new Publix and saw Buff City Soap! It was my first time seeing one in person, so I figured I'd grab a few photos for an MSRB contribution, and here we are today!


     Buff City Soap traces its origins back to 2013, so it's a relatively new company. The company was founded by Brad Kellum and his girlfriend Jennifer Ziemianin, who created a line of organic and plant-based soap products in Brad's garage after he began developing skin irritation from the chemicals in the soap he was previously using. After sharing the new soap product with friends, they began to develop an interest in buying his soap, leading Brad and Jennifer to start a side business with their new product. After experimenting with online sales at first, the couple made the leap into brick-and-mortar retail in 2014 when they opened in a small storefront at 3000 Kirby Whitten Road in the Memphis suburb of Bartlett. The original store, which opened under the name Bartlett Soap Company, is still in operation at that same location too - the first of what would become (as of early 2022) over 220 locations for Buff City Soap nationwide.


     During their first year in business, Brad and Jennifer sold $75,000 worth of soap, making the product a hit locally. The overwhelming response to the product led the couple to open a second location in Olive Branch, Mississippi, as well as a central manufacturing and distribution facility for the soap's ingredients. As sales grew, Buff City Soap began to offer franchising opportunities, which began the company's growth outside of Memphis and into new territories (like Florida).


     Currently, Buff City Soap has locations in most of the major metropolitan areas of Florida, with the location we'll be touring today located in the SoDo neighborhood of Orlando. SoDo is short for "South Downtown", and is a somewhat trendy urbanizing part of Orlando that builds off the urbanized feel of downtown, with some suburban characteristics thrown in. Buff City Soap fits in pretty well with the aesthetic of the area, especially as a store selling trendy organic products (like the supermarket that was originally intended to anchor this strip too). However, hiding amongst the new and trendy, in the background of the above photo there is a giant ice cream cone looking at us to break up the sight of all the gray paint and fake stone! That ice cream cone is part of Florida's famous Twistee Treat chain, a chain of ice cream shops famous for its cone-shaped buildings. Twistee Treat's history is a long story for another day, but the article I linked to is a nice little summary of the company's original downfall and modern revival.


     Cleaning ourselves from that distraction about ice cream, we need to return our attention to soap! Pictured here is the front entrance to the SoDo Buff City Soap store. Unfortunately, I didn't go inside for any pictures, but the remainder of this post will feature a few interior shots I pulled from Google Maps of this location so everyone can get a little feel of what one of these stores is like:

Photo courtesy of Google Maps Reviews

     The SoDo location of Buff City Soap opened in July 2021, as part of the company's grand plan to expand nationwide. That expansion has been fueled in the late 2010s and early 2020s due to a large interest from potential franchisees, who have been submitting applications to open a Buff City Soap location of their own in all corners of the country. Thanks to the franchise model, Buff City Soap has been able to sustain the rapid growth, growing from a handful of locations around Memphis in 2017 to over 200 locations nationwide today. The company's plans include growing to over 1,000 locations by 2025, but to sustain that growth, a sacrifice to the Mid-South was made. In 2020, Buff City Soap announced it was moving its headquarters from Memphis to Dallas, Texas, due to Dallas's proximity to potential private investors and the local talent pool. A bit of a sad move for a company that has a nod to Memphis right in its name, but business is business I suppose. However, Buff City Soap will always be able to trace its roots to the Mid-South, even if the company did have to run off to Texas to attract the big money.

Photo courtesy of Google Maps Reviews

     The interior of a Buff City Soap location involves many tables and shelves of soap, as you'd expect. Officially, Buff City Soap calls their stores "soap makeries", as all of the product sold in the store is made in the store, an interesting twist on the traditional way of selling soap. Only the raw ingredients for the soap products are shipped to each location, with the store employees responsible for making all the bars and bottles of soap sold in store.

Photo courtesy of Google Maps Reviews

     More soap...

Photo courtesy of Google Maps Reviews

     Even more soap...

Photo courtesy of Google Maps Reviews

     Laundry soap too - Buff City really has all aspects of soap covered in here!

Photo courtesy of Google Maps Reviews

     The laundry soap department even has a (very real looking) washer and dryer too.

Photo courtesy of Google Maps Reviews

     For a store that only sells soap, this place is pretty big. Buff City occupies the oversized corner space of the little strip mall it is located in, and they were able to fill that space with a lot of soap! The photos online show a decent number of people in the store too, so hopefully with all the soap sales, this place is really cleaning up!

Photo courtesy of Google Maps Reviews

     In addition to all the employee-made soaps for sale, Buff City also had a small counter where customers could make their own soaps too - a fun little offering!

Photo courtesy of Google Maps Reviews

     So that wraps up our little tour of a Buff City Soap store, Memphis's most recent contribution to the national retail scene (as seen in Florida).


     It's nice to see how a small idea can still lead someone to create a large chain like we saw in the case of Buff City Soap. While I see a lot of new start-up restaurant chains popping up rather frequently, a retail chain starting from scratch like this seems to be a rarity anymore - especially a chain that started as a person's crazy idea in a garage, and not a chain created by an existing large company. Even though the company is no longer headquartered in Memphis, hopefully Buff City Soap will continue to prosper for many years to come, and continue to represent Memphis and the Mid-South through its name.

     To finish out this post, I have to give a big thanks to Retail Retell for letting me contribute to the Mid-South Retail Blog once again, and maybe he'll let me write on his blog again when I find another way to cut back on the puns blend Floridian and Mid-South retail together! More to come from Retail Retell on The Mid-South Retail Blog in the future as well, and he always has something going on over at his flickr photostream in case things ever slow down on here again too. You can also find more from myself at my namesake Albertsons Florida Blog and its sister blog, My Florida Retail, if you want to keep up with the craziness that is Floridian retail.

     So like one bubble said to the other bubble, it's time for me to pop on out of here. Until next time, thanks for reading, and have fun exploring the retail world wherever you are!

AFB

Celebrating Seven Years of The Mid-South Retail Blog!


Happy 2022, everybody, and happy seventh anniversary to the Mid-South Retail Blog! It's hard to believe I've been doing this for over seven years now, and that so many of you have followed along for a majority of that time. I'm very grateful for each of you, and also deeply appreciative to the new followers who have discovered this blog more recently. It's my hope that the content I post will attract readers looking for publications about those topics, and I've heard from several folks who have helped me understand that, at least to a certain extent, I'm realizing that accomplishment, which is of course a wonderful feeling.

2022 has gotten off to a quiet start so far here on the blog, thanks to how busy I've been at work. My flickr photostream has slowed down considerably as well, although I've still managed to (just barely!) keep up with that, for the time being. In the meantime, I didn't want my blog posts to suffer in quality, so I decided simply not to post anything at all for a little while. Hopefully, if everything works out, I envision posts resuming sometime next month or in May, with the caveat that they will still likely be more spread out than they were in the past (i.e., not necessarily once per month any longer). So please be sure to stay tuned for that. And also today, in addition to this annual anniversary post, we have yet another special guest author feature from my friend Albertsons Florida Blog, so please go and check that out if you haven't already!

As of the time I'm writing this (which is about a week and a half before the anniversary itself), our pageviews stand at 148,819, which is an increase of 29,289 over last year's 119,530 -- the highest yearly jump in pageviews we've had since our second anniversary, so thank you all for that! Remember that contributor posts or just plain discussions are welcome at any time via our inbox at midsouthretailblog [at] gmail [dot] com. And in case you'd like to revisit any of our posts from the past year, feel free to do so using any of the links below, or whenever you please using the sidebar on the web version of the blog.

January 2021

February 2021

March 2021

April 2021

May 2021

June 2021

August 2021

September 2021

November 2021
Former Albertsons #4317 - Mobile, AL (a guest post by Retail Retell on the Albertsons Florida Blog)

December 2021

Thanks again, sincerely, to all of you for making this a great seven years, and look forward to more new content coming to the blog soon! Until then, be sure (again) to check out our other new post today from AFB, and as always, have fun exploring the retail world wherever you are :)

Retail Retell