Tuesday, August 16, 2016

Kroger Marketplace, Mansfield, OH


I know this is another out-of-market post. For that, I apologize. However, with Mid-Southerners on the heels of Kroger's first Marketplace location opening locally (in Hernando, MS; I have an album covering its construction here) and more either in the planning stages or under construction already, I thought this post would be a great way to introduce the concept to any readers interested in getting a glimpse of just what exactly a Kroger Marketplace is like ahead of time.


I didn't get any really good shots of the exterior on my visit. However, it was slightly different than the standard design that many Kroger Marketplaces, including Hernando's, have. I imagine this is because the Mansfield Marketplace was one of Kroger's first, as with many in Ohio, considering Kroger is based out of Cincinnati.


The right-side, grocery vestibule featured a bit of a general merchandise display...


...before opening into the fresh departments.


Starbucks is directly to the left inside the entrance.


Floral along the front wall


Kitchen Place isn't necessarily exclusive to Marketplaces; many Kroger stores have this sort of merchandise. However, they don't typically have this large of a selection.




Produce is in the front right corner, and down the side wall beyond the department is natural foods and the deli-bakery.



Some closer looks at the décor package. I love the wood look!



The wine section had this neat hanging fixture



Any item imaginable can be found at a Kroger Marketplace, haha!




A look at the bakery, joined by a couple of shots across the actionway back toward produce


The back aisle of the store



Whether due to local laws or not, the liquor store is enclosed in its own little store-within-a-store, which I thought was pretty neat.



The meat department. Aside from a presumably expanded selection and different décor, this doesn't look all that unlike a modern non-Marketplace Kroger, in my opinion.


Beverages are just to the left of Kitchen Place, if you're looking from the front of the store toward the back (this picture does the opposite). We've definitely seen those 2012/bountiful décor gooseneck signs before! We've also seen a variation of the Marketplace-style price scanner sign too, believe it or not...



Frozen meats and the transition to dairy


The "pet" circle sign is another example of 2012 décor. There are a few examples of it, but mostly the Marketplace décor is prevalent.



Frozen foods is around center store. I like the hanging sign!


A few of the carts here even had specially labeled handles!


Entering the general merchandise area of the store. I didn't have much time to look around at the selection, but as you'll see, the area this section takes up is pretty massive. The lower shelves make it a little easier to navigate than your typical hypermarket as well.


The hanging signs in this department are made of fabric, I believe.


Though these are obviously 2012-style, the blue product markers for toys likely have to be exclusive to Marketplaces. Interesting!


A center aisle splits the GM departments on this side of frozen foods. I believe all of the grocery aisles on the other side run the entire length of the store from front to back, with no break.


Close-up of a cool fabric sign. I may be wrong about the material. If anyone has any better guesses, please leave them in the comments!


The aisle signs also have bountiful décor placards.


Flash sales seem like something to look forward to!


A look across the back aisle again, this time from the left of the store over to the right. Again, this store - and all Marketplaces - are just expansive!



The Mansfield Kroger Marketplace holds significance because it was the first of the prototypes to feature clothing, added in 2012 with the remodel to Kroger's current Marketplace décor. You can read more about that here. Prior to this rollout, Kroger Marketplaces sold furniture; clothing wound up being its replacement.


Even the flooring here had some sort of décor on it, lol!



The fitting rooms for clothing are in the back left corner of the store. In newer Marketplaces (built after clothing became a permanent fixture), clothing tends to be closer to the front of the store.


Yet another back aisle view


Looking from clothing across the left side of the store toward the pharmacy in the front left corner.



The pharmacy had signage on both the side wall...


...and front wall.


A look across the front actionway from pharmacy


Gotta love that department signage!


Although I don't like that Kroger has moved from using the infinitely more interesting Rockwell font (seen above) to bland ol' Arial (EDIT: Helvetica, not Arial; thanks 11110) in their promotional signs, I have always thought that their use of quotes in said promotional signage has been kinda dumb. As if anyone actually literally said, "Low prices on great store brands... all under $5!" (/grammar freak)


Since Kroger owns the Fred Meyer brand, Fred Meyer Jewelers are common features in Marketplaces. Mansfield's was closed at the time of night I visited. The Mid-South Kroger Marketplaces reportedly will not be getting jewelry stores, so it will be interesting to see what takes up that space (since Marketplaces seem to mostly be built according to the same designs, although the next Mid-South one to open - fall 2017 in Arlington, TN - will feature a completely different look)


A look across the promo/deals/seasonal aisle back toward dairy along the rear of the store


The front end.


The tobacco sign is a remnant from this store's previous Marketplace décor!


Guest care and money services are present, as usual, in addition to a bank, as seen in an earlier shot.


 

If you follow my posts on flickr, you know I have an album dedicated to 12s I (at first unintentionally, and now purposely) have found in my retail photography journeys. This store, it turns out, does not have an Aisle 12 sign (instead, the 2012 décor pet circle sign is in its place - yuck! :P )... so I took a pic of register 12 instead ;)


The self checkout wall you see here is the back of the Starbucks stand.


A look into floral and produce before exiting again through the right-side entrance...


One last exterior close-up, and that concludes our tour of the Mansfield, OH, Kroger Marketplace! Hopefully this gives those of you interested an idea of what a Kroger Marketplace is like. Certainly it's an experience to behold! Beyond that, it must also be comparable to stores such as Walmart, considering the concept's success in the markets in which it is present. Hopefully the Mid-South will be receptive of them as well!

As for the history of the Kroger Marketplace concept... Raymie Humbert (who you may remember as having provided the pics for the Marketplace section of this décor post) has a few words to say on that:

To understand Marketplace, we have to go to the mid-late 90s, and more specifically to a disappeared store name in the Kroger heritage, Smitty's. Smitty's was a chain founded by Clyde "Smitty" Smith in Iowa in 1948. It expanded to Arizona in 1961, and the AZ operation remained fairly separate from the IA/MO unit.

In 1996, Smitty's Arizona was sold to Smith's which led to the two banners operating together in Phoenix and total conversion to Smith's in Tucson. The next year, Smith's was bought by Fred Meyer as part of its massive expansion (it also bought QFC and Ralph's at this time), and over the next couple years Smith's and Smitty's disappeared to bring the Fred Meyer banner to Arizona.

It was in the last few years of Smitty's when the Marketplace format was pioneered. These were very large grocery stores containing garden centers, expanded non-grocery departments with more SKUs for household items, patio furniture, and electronics up front. The two nearest Marketplaces, both built in the mid-90s, had attached Blockbuster Video locations with entrances from the store. Two stores were piloted in 1997, and five came on for 1998, with another 11 opened by the end of the decade. To do this, food courts in some 20 former Smitty's stores closed.

(Fred Meyer, however, never operated its traditional superstore format in the Southwest. The closest it came was its acquisition of the Smitty's Marketplace stores.)

In February 1999, the Smitty's name disappeared and the entire chain became Fred Meyer. I believe all the remaining Smitty's stores were Marketplaces by that point.

I recall seeing the Fred Meyer name until 2000, a year after FM turned around and merged with Kroger. Kroger, sensing an opportunity for market domination and already owning a banner in the state, bid adieu to the Fred Meyer and Smith's banners in Arizona (with some exceptions in northern Arizona where the Smith's name hangs on) and converted them to Fry's stores. Remodeling was not part of this conversion as most of the Marketplace stores had just been renovated in recent years.

I actually have Smitty's Marketplace and Fred Meyer Marketplace magnets. I recall thinking the latter were a little off because they had 602 on them as the area code when Phoenix was split in three and the store was now in a new area code.

In the 2000s, propagated from the Smitty's AZ chain to the rest of Kroger. The serif "Marketplace" logo still used throughout the chain was introduced with the conversion of the Fred Meyer Marketplace stores to the Fry's banner.

My 1996/97-vintage original Smitty's Marketplace has received two major renovations. The original look had a lot of orange, purple and triangle accents - the last piece of it in the store is documented in the Remodel Diaries, too! The first concluded in 2005 and featured a package I've never seen documented that was itself a kinda cheap derivative of a similar look used as early as 2003. It also enclosed the garden center, which had fallen into disuse, for more store space. The second was the current generation Marketplace decor and is the one featured in the Remodel Diaries; it was far more exhaustive in terms of involving a lot of demolition and reconstruction. (They reclaimed the Blockbuster for store space and rearranged several departments.)

I still can't believe they managed to do that store renovation in three months, and in doing so they finally made the decision to just have one store at the intersection (a script decor Fry's was at the same intersection and operated there until just after the renovation completed).

One last treat before we end the post... a really old Kroger trailer featuring their old "Right Store. Right Price." slogan and their Private Selection store brand prior to its revamp! I saw this on the way home from my visit to Ohio and unfortunately was unable to get the entire trailer in one image. Still, it was a neat sight, and I hope my photos help you to get the picture!







You can see some more pics of old Private Selection products here. Additionally, for more pics of a Kroger Marketplace store (and one that's more local, too!), l_dawg2000 has an album covering the Jonesboro, AR, store here. The Hernando Kroger Marketplace is set to open sometime very soon - September 1st, I had heard, although that may or may not turn out to be the truth. Additionally, both the Hernando store and the new Union Avenue Kroger under construction in Midtown Memphis are set to have localized murals, which I think is really neat!

That's what you can expect Kroger Marketplaces to be like... until next time, have fun exploring the retail world wherever you are!

Retail Retell

11 comments:

  1. Seeing a Kroger Marketplace for the first time must be an experience! It's much more expansive than I thought after seeing this comprehensive photo tour of one for the first time. I really like the concept of Kroger Marketplace. While their general merchandise selection isn't as expansive as in Walmart's Supercenters, it covers enough of the basics to where one can do just about all of their shopping at Kroger Marketplace instead. Not only that, but the KM decor is much nicer than anything Walmart could come up with! (That wood paneling behind the department signs is really nice!) If I lived near one of these, I'd definitely do much of my shopping here.

    I always thought clothing was an original part of the Kroger Marketplace store's GM selection, so that's new to me. Furniture seemed like an odd move for Kroger (although I have seen regular grocery stores with full patio furniture departments, but not sofas or anything like that!). For a grocery company, clothing seems like much less of a pain to deal with, and allows for better impulse buying while grocery shopping than furniture would be.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'll still probably do my shopping at Walmart, simply because it's closest to where I live in town and that's where we've shopped for years. But if the Kroger were closer, I bet we'd be the opposite!

      I agree with all that. Probably why Kroger decided to get out of the furniture business, haha! I want to say that came over from the predecessor Marketplaces, but I'm not sure.

      Delete
  2. I haven't been in a Marketplace myself, so I haven't experienced it, but I'll add a few things.

    1- Kroger switched the font from Rockwell to Helvetica, not Arial. There's a few differences between the two (Uppercase G and R for example). Target and CVS use this font as well.

    2- Kroger running Flash sales is interesting. I've never seen them run one before (even though Harris Teeter does them quite often)

    3- Speaking of Harris Teeter, plans have been put in place for a 100,000 square foot store in NC. If this one doesn't downsize, then we could potentially see that division running a Marketplace style store. (Every state that surrounds NC already has a Kroger Marketplace)

    4- I believe Fred Meyer also has a Marketplace or two laying around, so I don't think it was just Smitty's that did it. Ralphs might have had some Marketplaces too, but those are totally different from the Kroger Marketplace stores we see today.

    5- The Jewelry store space could end up being the ClickList prep area. ClickList is based off of Harris Teeter ExpressLane, and they do require refrigerated units up front so orders could be ready to go.

    Marketplaces could be considered Hypermarkets, but not necessarily in the way that the Walmarts, Meijers,and Targets of the world are. Marketplaces lack some of the sections the other three have (Electronics, Home improvement, and Sporting goods come to mind), and most of the sales floor space at Kroger Marketplace is still dedicated to items found at Supermarkets.


    I remember FMV, Private Selection and Big K before their early 2010s revamps. I kind of miss the old packaging for Big K/ Big K Coolers

    Anyway, Congrats on reaching a big milestone.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. 1- Ah, gotcha. Thanks; I've updated the post. It's the blandest use of Helvetica I've ever seen, then!

      2- I've never seen one either. Who knows if it's a divisional or chainwide thing in Marketplaces.

      3- Cool!

      4- You're right, I think. The excerpt mentions Fred Meyer Marketplaces :)

      5- Maybe so. I think l_dawg2000 said the ClickList area in the Jonesboro Marketplace is in the back of that store, though. I personally think the jewelry space would be good for ClickList, although the plans may have been altered to exclude the space altogether once they determined the stores wouldn't feature Fred Meyer.

      Yeah, I was trying to say that compared to hypermarkets like the ones you mention, the Kroger Marketplaces' shelving seems to be a little shorter in height. I get that it's mostly still just a grocery store, and I think that's probably key to their success.

      Me too! And thanks!

      Delete
    2. FM seems to have opened its first FM Marketplace stores in 1996 - in Seattle and Silverdale, Washington. At the time, the chain acknowledged the concept was "not new". That said, I'm not quite sure they were the same because of the order of acquisitions. Smith's bought Smitty's in 1996, and FM bought Smith's the very next year (and the year after, Kroger merged with FM - leading to some very rapid changes in banner, such as the Smitty's name being disappeared in 1999 and its stores run by the FM division, only for them to be merged with the Fry's (and former Smith's) stores the next year).

      Also, I got around to posting this:

      https://www.flickr.com/photos/65289109@N04/28976890222/

      I found a bit more on FM's attempt to build a full-style store in Phoenix, too. It would have been located at 3324 W. Bethany Home Road (at 35th Avenue) next to an existing Marketplace (probably a former Smitty's). It didn't happen due to the Kroger merger, and the store ended up closing when a new-build Fry's went in one mile west at 43rd Avenue. There's a Walmart Supercenter and a very recent-looking shopping strip there instead.

      Delete
  3. Sorry for the deletions...I've been going on not much sleep and I realize what I posted didn't come across the way I wanted it to. With that said...

    Even though, it's out of the MSRB range, it's nice to see Ohio show up on the blog! I really enjoyed reading this post and the pictures are great! Decor-wise, this one is a little bit nicer than mine--I really like the wall treatment above the pharmacy.

    We've been pretty loyal to our marketplace ever since we moved into the area; their natural foods selection is quite large with relatively decent prices. We don't do too much in the way of apparel shopping there, but we have in the past and sometimes they have great deals.

    I'm sure you'll enjoy your Hernando Marketplace when it opens!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. No problem - I got rid of them permanently for you :)

      Thanks! I like the décor a lot too. Sounds like some elements of this were dropped over time, such as the checkout lights and frozen overhead sign, according to l_dawg2000 on the corresponding flickr photo I posted. This must have been one of the first ones to get this décor, and maybe the first ever!

      Sounds good! I'm sure looking forward to it!

      Delete
  4. Yep, this store definitely has more of a Marketplace look than the newer Jonesboro store, but doesn't really make me like the that store any less! Apparel up front definitely makes more sense, and gives the store a nicer look as well (odd seeing clothes next to dairy cases :P). And with produce along a wall (in a corner no less, if I understood correctly), I guess they had no choice here but to have produce related décor in this particular store. Hopefully the new Marketplace in Hernando will get a few of those elements (although likely not the produce décor seen here) that Jonesboro missed out on!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hopefully so! And yeah, you're right about produce being in the front right corner here, again likely due to the earlier layout style that also produced the clothing by dairy :P

      Delete
  5. That wood sign is fantastic looking! I would like to see more things done like that. Having the liquor as a store within a store is a cool idea as well.

    You and you're 12's. Is that your favorite number? :D

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree!

      Haha! It's not actually, but most stores don't have an aisle number as high as my favorite :P It has ended up as one I purposefully capture whenever I can now though, simply because I always seemed to capture it unintentionally beforehand!

      Delete

Have any info to share, or simply want to join the discussion? Please feel free to leave a comment! Comments are welcome on any and all posts so long as you adopt a username and do not post any malicious links. Comments are subject to moderation before being approved, so please be patient if your comment does not appear automatically. Please remain civil in your comments. If we decide your comment is inappropriate, we reserve the right to delete it.

Disclaimer: The Mid-South Retail Blog exists solely for educational and historical purposes. This blog claims no ownership of, or relation to, any organization, retail or otherwise, whose property may be featured in pictures or in links within posts. We are not affiliated with, or endorsed by, any entity featured on the blog. However, we do claim ownership of our content, unless it is credited otherwise. If you find any inaccuracies in our posts, please let us know in the comments or via email so that we can make any necessary changes. Information on the blog may be frequently updated without notice.